 |
Page History
...
Software Name and Web Site |
|
| |||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Interface/GUI | Web | Web | Web/Desktop Application | ||||||||||||||||
Query types/flexibility | Simple (9 parameters), Advanced (10 more parameters), Dynamic (boolean query of up to 90 DICOM tags) | Limited subset of DICOM tags out of the box but is highly configurable for adding the ability to query on just about any kind of meta data you wish to provide | Customizable, search by any tags registered in the system | ||||||||||||||||
Role Based Security | Yes | Yes | Yes | ||||||||||||||||
Public access option (no login req) | Yes | Yes | Yes | ||||||||||||||||
Active Development | Yes, NCI CBIIT | Yes, WUSTL Neuroinformatics Research Group | Yes, Kitware | ||||||||||||||||
License | Open source - NBIA License Agreement Details | Non-restrictive (BSD) open-source license - XNAT License Agreement Details
| non-restrictive (BSD) open-source license | ||||||||||||||||
Supports Federated Implementation | Yes, can discover other nodes on the caGrid | Not currently, but there are plans to add this functionality eventually | No | ||||||||||||||||
API available | Yes, caGrid | Yes, REST | Yes, REST, OAI-PMH | ||||||||||||||||
Supported image formats | DICOM | Automated import of DICOM and ECAT. Custom importers can be implemented for other formats. Any file type can be uploaded through the API and web interface. | DICOM and other ITK-based format | ||||||||||||||||
Supported metadata formats | XML, Zip | XML | XML | ||||||||||||||||
Transfer protocols (import/export) | DICOM, HTTPS | DICOM, HTTPS | DICOM, HTTPS | ||||||||||||||||
Controlled Vocabulary | Follows caBIG standards (caDSR/EVS) | XNAT Schema | NIH Mesh and Dublin Core | ||||||||||||||||
Deployment Support | Yes, CBIIT Application Support or via NBIA User Listserv | XNAT Google Discussion group, monthly developer tcons, biannual user conference | Yes, MIDAS mailing list | ||||||||||||||||
Support Operating Systems | Linux, Windows, Mac | Linux, Windows, Mac | Linux, Windows, Mac | ||||||||||||||||
Data submission options | Submission to NBIA is performed by a java tool called CTP
| Direct upload is available through the web UI, direct DICOM transfer, scripts using REST API. | Direct upload via web UI, direct DICOM transfer via push, MIDASDesktop transfer (includes command line tools), WebDAV support. | ||||||||||||||||
Standard of De-Identification | Incorporates DICOM de-identification standards from The Attribute Confidentiality Profile (DICOM PS 3.15: Appendix E) via CTP. | Built-in de-identification language based on DICOM Browser
| No, but pre-storage filters can be run automatically | ||||||||||||||||
Support for multi-site submissions | Yes | Yes | Yes |
