NIH | National Cancer Institute | NCI Wiki  

Error rendering macro 'rw-search'

null

Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Section 6 > Overview of Semantic Infrastructure 2.0 Capabilities and Services
"Reasoning and Inference": it is not clear how inference is different from reasoning, except that it might be more specific. I think this should just be "Reasoning" or in correspondence with earlier "Decision Support". Later it turns even in "Knowledge Engineering, Inference, and Reasoning".
Resolution:
Reluctant to reduce to just reasoning since it may be argued that not all reasoning is inference, but made this consistent. What is missing are the actual functional profiles. Eric Schripsema

The purpose of the functional profiles is not clear: it seems a one-to-one mapping of the functional requirements. Additionally, the paragraph above that explains the relation with the corresponding OASIS Reference Models, Ontologies, and Architecture is unclear: why are these standards in this document represented as Semantic Profiles, and what is the relation with the following functional profiles.
Resolution:
The profiles are the bulleted items, and are organized in the document according to the requirements. Eric Schripsema

Similar remarks as for Section 5 hold. For example, that service discovery would allow service developers to specify rich metadata (this is the other way around).
Resolution:
This service is the enabling service which allows the expression of the metadata and is therefore correct. Eric Schripsema