Link to page: 9 - CBIIT Project Recommendations
Comments on November 22 version:
Section 9 > Tools Recommended for Semantic Infrastructure Work
Missing reference to CBIIT supported standards.
Resolution:
Section 9 > Tools Recommended for Semantic Infrastructure Work > Triple Store Access
Specify that ARQ supports the W3C standard SPARQL.
Resolution:
Section 9 > Tools Recommended for Semantic Infrastructure Work > Semantic Knowledge
Store
Meaningless sentence: "and datasets which can be used in a way which will allow for some amount of use within service environments"
Resolution:
Section 9 > Tools Recommended for Semantic Infrastructure Work > Inference, Rules and Expert Systems
Additional to RuleML, RIF -- http://www.w3.org/TR/rif-overview/
-- should be mentioned as the standard for rule exchange (it does for rules what OWL did for Description Logics).
Resolution:
Section 9 > Tools Recommended for Semantic Infrastructure Work > Inference, Rules and Expert Systems > RDF and OWL Tools
I would put TopBraid SPIN together with ARQ, rather than with the RDF and OWL tools, as it would only support a small fragment of OWL namely OWL 2 RL (and is as such not a full OWL reasoner).
Resolution:
Section 9 > Tools Recommended for Semantic Infrastructure Work > Inference, Rules and Expert Systems > General Purpose
A section for pure rule reasoners seems to be missing (Jess and Drools are production rules engines), what is with reasoners such as Ontobroker (http://www.ontoprise.de/en/home/ products/ontobroker/ ), FLORA-2 ( http://flora.sourceforge.net/ ), dlv ( http://www.dlvsystem.com/dlvsystem/index.php/Home ), dlvhex ( http://www.kr.tuwien.ac.at/research/systems/dlvhex/ ), and others?
Resolution: